Sarah Fuller: Will We See More Non-Male Athletes Playing On Men’s Teams?

ByAndrew Pistone

6 min read

Sarah Fuller: Will We See More Non-Male Athletes Playing On Men’s Teams?

There are certain moments in sports that reach fans and society differently. Where were you when Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier? What were you doing when Billie Jean King beat Bobby Riggs in the “Battle of the Sexes” tennis match?

Most readers of this piece are probably too young to personally remember those events (myself included), but keep your eyes and ears peeled for events that will change the game as we know it forever.

Last Saturday, Sarah Fuller made history by kicking off the second half of Vanderbilt’s football game against the University of Missouri with a squib kick. She was the first woman to play in a Power Five conference men’s football game in the history of college athletics.

Fuller was already a student athlete at Vanderbilt University, playing goalie for the women’s soccer team. It took an extraordinary set of circumstances for this opportunity to arise, as many Vanderbilt Commodores special teams players were in quarantine due to Covid-19.

But it can make fans realize that women or non-male athletes are not as low on the emergency depth chart list as one might imagine, if another running back, linebacker or tight end couldn’t just kick for a team in a pinch.

While Fuller’s demolition of the glass ceiling as it relates to playing football at the highest collegiate level occurred last weekend, this is not the first time a female has competed in a men’s college football game.

Back in 2003, Katie Hnida became the first woman to score points in an NCAA Division I-A game, by converting two extra point attempts against Texas State for the New Mexico Lobos of the Mountain West Conference. In addition to being a worthy kicker, she also took pride in being a part of the team, and participating in drills that all of her male teammates were doing.

Six years earlier, Liz Heaston of Willamette University had the distinction of being the first woman to appear in a college football game, and the first to score points.

First woman to play in college football game, at Willamette University, reflects on her experience
Liz Heaston was the first woman to play in a college football game at Willamette University in Oregon.

She knocked through two extra points against Linfield College in 1997. Heaston had a similar athletic background to Fuller, also starring on the university soccer team before being asked to kick for the men’s football team.

Much more recently, a young lady from Detroit made history by receiving what was believed to be the first football scholarship for a woman who was not a kicker.

Antoinette Harris, who goes by “Toni”, is currently a scholarship defensive back for Central Methodist University in Missouri, after having spent the first two years of her career playing for East Los Angeles College. Harris’s journey has gotten a lot of attention from the media, including being featured in a Super Bowl commercial.

Harris’ opportunity to play football on a scholarship with the Central Methodist University Eagles does seem to expand the horizons of amateur athletes everywhere who might want to play a sport that is traditionally reserved for another gender.

On the scholarship page of CMU’s website, the institution lists several sports and extracurricular disciplines that are eligible for “participatory scholarships”, and does not appear to include any gender specific requirements or qualifications for sports where the school only has a male team.

The main stipulation for the scholarship is that the student athlete (in the case of sports scholarships) must tryout/interview with an athletic director or coach to be considered.

In reviewing the scholarship guidelines on the NCAA website and other sources, it does not appear that schools make a specific distinction that scholarships for male sports programs can only be offered to men. This leaves the door open for supremely talented female athletes to receive athletic scholarships on traditionally male athletic teams, and while probably not as common, for the reverse situation to happen as well.

One reason why the scholarship requirements might be written to allow for as much latitude as they do could be the effect of Title IX law in the United States.

Title IX was put into place in 1972, and forbids educational institutions who receive federal funds(which are the vast majority of schools), from discriminating against students or faculty based on gender. The NCAA has a frequently asked questions section devoted to how Title IX affects athletics—here is an excerpt from the site addressing how it is meant to be applied:

Athletics programs are considered educational programs and activities. There are three basic parts of Title IX as it applies to athletics:

1. Participation: Title IX requires that women and men be provided equitable opportunities to participate in sports. Title IX does not require institutions to offer identical sports but an equal opportunity to play;
2. Scholarships: Title IX requires that female and male student-athletes receive athletics scholarship dollars proportional to their participation; and
3. Other benefits: Title IX requires the equal treatment of female and male student-athletes in the provisions of: (a) equipment and supplies; (b) scheduling of games and practice times; (c) travel and daily allowance/per diem; (d) access to tutoring; (e) coaching, (f) locker rooms, practice and competitive facilities; (g) medical and training facilities and services; (h) housing and dining facilities and services; (i) publicity and promotions; (j) support services and (k) recruitment of student-athletes

The first application of Title IX can be interpreted as good news for athletes of all genders, since that lends itself to the notion that athletic programs are obligated to at least provide opportunities for athletes to showcase their skills.

If a woman wanted to play football on a men’s team, and could reasonably help the team in a more impactful way than a male counterpart in any facet of the game, and there was no option for her to play on a women’s football team at the school, then this suggests that a school would be obligated to at least provide the female athlete with a tryout.

The ultimate decision of whether to offer the athlete a scholarship or a spot on the team would still ultimately rest with the coaches and athletic directors, but that decision, by law, cannot be made for gender-related reasons—it would have to be based on the athletic and academic merits of the athlete.

Additionally, reviewing section 3 of the above excerpt from the NCAA website can also be viewed as positive news in this scenario. It can be interpreted that if a female is selected to play on a men’s football team, whether on scholarship or not, they will be permitted to receive the same educational, nutritional, and physical perks the men do.

Moreover, subsection (j) of that paragraph also references support services—while that’s a general term, if that includes counseling or a sports psychology options, it would be tremendously beneficial to a female player to have someone to talk to while being the minority on an otherwise all male roster.

If Fuller, Heaston, Harris and other women have proven anything, it’s that technicalities and bylaws are just words on a page. If the talent and hunger to push oneself out of their comfort zone and break the mold, institutions and society as a whole will have no choice but to listen.

“I try to speak to girls and try to keep them motivated in playing the game.  No matter what, keep your head held high. Do not let anybody tell you this, that, and the other things. Don’t let anyone kill your dream,” Harris said.
Are you an Athlete?

Create a free profile to access the largest network specifically designed to connect athletes to opportunities. Get started.

RELATED ARTICLES
2024 WNBA Draft Recap: Caitlin Clark Goes No. 1, Fever and Sparks Shine

2024 WNBA Draft Recap: Caitlin Clark Goes No. 1, Fever and Sparks Shine

The 2024 WNBA Draft saw the Indiana Fever select Caitlin Clark with the first overall pick, adding...

ByBen Gauthier | Tue Apr 16 2024
Sports Apps: The Future of Sports Engagement and Fan Interaction

Sports Apps: The Future of Sports Engagement and Fan Interaction

In the increasingly digital world we live in, it comes as no surprise that sports engagement and...

ByTiffany Allen | Thu Aug 24 2023
Artificial Intelligence: A Game-Changer for the Sports Industry

Artificial Intelligence: A Game-Changer for the Sports Industry

Artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming industries across the board, revolutionizing the way...

ByTiffany Allen | Mon Aug 21 2023
USA Football: Two NFL Teams To Provide Coach Certification To Support Youth Football

USA Football: Two NFL Teams To Provide Coach Certification To Support Youth Football

The Indianapolis Colts and the Cleveland Browns have announced their support for USA Football's...

ByTiffany Allen | Thu May 04 2023
Ontario Volleyball Association: February/March - News and Updates

Ontario Volleyball Association: February/March - News and Updates

A new season means new events and opportunities for volleyball athletes across Canada. As the...

ByOVA Team Ontario | Thu Mar 30 2023
Athletes Who Earned Their USA Football Tryout Invite on GMTM

Athletes Who Earned Their USA Football Tryout Invite on GMTM

Does football season really end anymore? The day after the Super Bowl, which marks the end of the...

ByScotty Jenkins | Mon Mar 06 2023
When Values Clash: Tackling the Alignment Problem for Sports Organizations and Athletes

When Values Clash: Tackling the Alignment Problem for Sports Organizations and Athletes

More than a century ago, Teddy Roosevelt Jr's injury during an amateur football game resulted in...

ByJoey Grant | Thu Mar 02 2023
How Many Scholarships Does Each Collegiate Sport Offer?

How Many Scholarships Does Each Collegiate Sport Offer?

It's time to start applying for schools and begin your recruiting process. You have been working...

ByJohnathan Wright | Tue Feb 21 2023
Tackling Sports Industry Fragmentation by Creating Athlete-First Solutions

Tackling Sports Industry Fragmentation by Creating Athlete-First Solutions

The sports industry is undergoing rapid change, putting pressure on organizations to keep pace. To...

ByJoey Grant | Mon Feb 06 2023
New XFL Draft Picks use GMTM to be seen by coaches and fans

New XFL Draft Picks use GMTM to be seen by coaches and fans

In just under a month, the XFL will be taking yet another crack at creating a competing...

ByScotty Jenkins | Fri Jan 20 2023
College Soccer: What is the difference between NCAA Division-I & NAIA?

College Soccer: What is the difference between NCAA Division-I & NAIA?

Many soccer athletes across the United States aspire to play their sport at the college level, and...

ByScotty Jenkins | Sat Nov 26 2022
What is a 'Draw'? And Why Ties Still Exist in the World's Most Popular Sport

What is a 'Draw'? And Why Ties Still Exist in the World's Most Popular Sport

When it comes to the growing popularity of soccer in the United States, perhaps one of the...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Nov 23 2022
Do They Have High School Sports In European Countries?

Do They Have High School Sports In European Countries?

Unlike the United States, European countries do not have high school athletics. It is a completely...

ByScotty Jenkins | Tue Nov 22 2022
Which College Sports Mascots Are The Most Polarizing?

Which College Sports Mascots Are The Most Polarizing?

They’re one of the most crucial aspects to a college sports viewing experience. The players?...

ByAndrew Pistone | Mon Nov 21 2022
Soccer Coaching: The four most popular formations and why they work

Soccer Coaching: The four most popular formations and why they work

In soccer, formations define the different positions on the field taken by each player of a...

ByScotty Jenkins | Fri Nov 18 2022
Four Of The Most Important Skills Every Soccer Goalkeeper Has To Develop

Four Of The Most Important Skills Every Soccer Goalkeeper Has To Develop

Goalkeepers are really the only ones on the field who you can't compete without. Don't have a...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Nov 16 2022
How To Play Division-I College Football: Four Requirements For Every Athlete

How To Play Division-I College Football: Four Requirements For Every Athlete

It is no secret that it is often a young football athlete's dream to play their favorite sport at...

ByScotty Jenkins | Mon Nov 14 2022
Bucket List: Five More College Football Traditions You Need To See

Bucket List: Five More College Football Traditions You Need To See

Part two of some of the best division 1 college football game day traditions throughout the United...

ByScotty Jenkins | Sat Nov 05 2022
Bucket List: Five College Football Traditions You Need To See

Bucket List: Five College Football Traditions You Need To See

One of the best parts about college football are the traditions that have been around for decades....

ByScotty Jenkins | Sat Nov 05 2022
What are College Football’s New Overtime Rules?

What are College Football’s New Overtime Rules?

In the 21st century, major sports have had to walk an interesting tightrope. They’ve had to balance...

ByAndrew Pistone | Mon Oct 24 2022
Why Is Boise State’s Football Field Blue?

Why Is Boise State’s Football Field Blue?

Some of college football’s most daunting homefield advantages come to mind pretty quickly. The Big...

ByAndrew Pistone | Tue Oct 11 2022
Think you can play college football? Here’s what to expect in the recruiting process

Think you can play college football? Here’s what to expect in the recruiting process

Playing college football is a dream for many high schoolers but the recruiting process can be...

ByScotty Jenkins | Thu Oct 06 2022
College Football's "Dead Money": Why Fired Coaches Keep Getting Paid

College Football's "Dead Money": Why Fired Coaches Keep Getting Paid

We’re at the point in the college football calendar where teams are assessing whether they’d like...

ByAndrew Pistone | Wed Sep 28 2022
Soccer Recruiting: What College Coaches Look For In High School Recruits

Soccer Recruiting: What College Coaches Look For In High School Recruits

Realistically, soccer coaches and managers look out for different things in soccer players during...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Sep 28 2022
What are "Guarantee Games" in College Football?

What are "Guarantee Games" in College Football?

As the 2022 college football season gets underway, there are many behemoth matchups on the calendar...

ByAndrew Pistone | Sun Sep 25 2022
College Football: Five Stars Who Could Have Benefitted Most from NIL Ruling

College Football: Five Stars Who Could Have Benefitted Most from NIL Ruling

The NCAA's Division I Board of Directors announced a new...

ByBryan Armetta | Sat Sep 24 2022
How Recruits Can Ask A School For More Athletic Scholarship Money

How Recruits Can Ask A School For More Athletic Scholarship Money

Athletes and parents often ask for college scholarship money during the athletic recruiting...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Sep 21 2022
What Does Redshirt Mean? And The Reasons Why Players Do It?

What Does Redshirt Mean? And The Reasons Why Players Do It?

Any athlete with a love for competition hates sitting on the sideline, but once he or she gets to...

ByCorey Roepken | Mon Sep 19 2022
EA Sports To Create College Football Video Game With These Updates

EA Sports To Create College Football Video Game With These Updates

After FOX Sports released a documentary on Christmas Day chronicling the life and career of the...

ByAndrew Pistone | Sat Sep 17 2022
Is playing College Soccer the best route to making the MLS?

Is playing College Soccer the best route to making the MLS?

Earlier this month, we witnessed the 2021 Major League...

ByJohnathan Wright | Sat Sep 17 2022
What CFB Programs Are Developing The Most NFL Talent At Each Position

What CFB Programs Are Developing The Most NFL Talent At Each Position

More than most sports, the fundamentals of Football change greatly depending on which position you...

ByAria Modirmassihai | Fri Sep 16 2022
College Football: Three Power 5 Quarterback Competitions to Keep Watching This Fall

College Football: Three Power 5 Quarterback Competitions to Keep Watching This Fall

Spring practice is underway for the nation's top college football programs, and that can only mean...

ByBryan Armetta | Thu Sep 08 2022
2022 College Football Cheat Sheet: Who Will Finish On Top In The Big Ten

2022 College Football Cheat Sheet: Who Will Finish On Top In The Big Ten

It's not the flashiest conference, nor is it the most talented, but Big Ten football offers...

ByBryan Armetta | Mon Sep 05 2022
College Football: Why Head Coach Salaries At Top Schools Keep Going Up

College Football: Why Head Coach Salaries At Top Schools Keep Going Up

What does one normally associate with the position of college football head coach? Leaders of men....

ByBryan Armetta | Sun Sep 04 2022
College Football: Are Spencer Rattler and South Carolina SEC East Contenders?

College Football: Are Spencer Rattler and South Carolina SEC East Contenders?

Competing in the SEC is not for everybody. Lost in the shuffle of the annual arms race between...

ByBryan Armetta | Sun Sep 04 2022
How Parents Can Help You Get Recruited To Play College Football

How Parents Can Help You Get Recruited To Play College Football

While performance and execution are a fundamental necessity for the child when it comes to getting...

ByDJ Cadden | Tue Aug 30 2022
5 Tips To Help Get Recruited To Play College Soccer

5 Tips To Help Get Recruited To Play College Soccer

The college soccer recruiting process can be extremely competitive, and unfortunately, it does not...

ByJohnathan Wright | Mon Aug 29 2022
College Football: Three Transfer Portal Players to Watch in 2022

College Football: Three Transfer Portal Players to Watch in 2022

It's not even four years old, but it's hard to even remember what college football was like before...

ByBryan Armetta | Sun Aug 28 2022
College Football: Four Of The Best College Towns In Division-I

College Football: Four Of The Best College Towns In Division-I

What makes a college sports town great? It certainly helps to eat, live and breathe the experience...

ByAndrew Pistone | Mon Aug 22 2022
How Does Recruiting Work in Today's CFB Landscape?

How Does Recruiting Work in Today's CFB Landscape?

Recruiting is an art that takes college football's elite programs years to truly perfect. Building...

ByBryan Armetta | Mon Aug 22 2022
Five Mediocre College Quarterbacks Who Had Great NFL Careers

Five Mediocre College Quarterbacks Who Had Great NFL Careers

We hear all the time about busts, especially at the quarterback position. These are the guys that...

ByBryan Armetta | Sun Aug 21 2022
College Soccer: Explaining how the best collegiate players turn professional

College Soccer: Explaining how the best collegiate players turn professional

For soccer players who want to play professionally, the path differs greatly from other major...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Aug 03 2022
Ranking the Five Best Division II Football Conferences

Ranking the Five Best Division II Football Conferences

While most fans are familiar with the prestigious football schools of the NCAA's Division I, the...

ByBryan Armetta | Thu Jul 28 2022
A GMTM Athlete’s Path to Success: Jordan McCray

A GMTM Athlete’s Path to Success: Jordan McCray

It’s a little unusual for a successful football player to only start playing the sport once they...

ByTiffany Allen | Thu Jul 28 2022
Soccer Coaching: What is each position in soccer responsible for?

Soccer Coaching: What is each position in soccer responsible for?

A proper soccer team will function at an optimal level when players in the team's setup understand...

ByScotty Jenkins | Sat Jul 16 2022
Football Coaches on Why You Should Not Add Music To Your Recruiting Highlights

Football Coaches on Why You Should Not Add Music To Your Recruiting Highlights

Coaches almost always head straight to the volume and shut it off when if it is on a recruits...

ByScotty Jenkins | Tue Jul 12 2022
Women's Gymnastics Development Program: How To Get Started With Team USA

Women's Gymnastics Development Program: How To Get Started With Team USA

If you are a part of the gymnastics world, people often ask questions like, " Exactly how wide is...

ByTiana Schoney | Thu Jul 07 2022
2022 College Football Conference Preview: Which Pac 12 Team Will End On Top

2022 College Football Conference Preview: Which Pac 12 Team Will End On Top

The Pac-12 hasn't seen a team reach the College Football Playoff since Washington in 2016. It's a...

ByBryan Armetta | Mon Jun 27 2022
Is USC Football Finally Back? Recapping Lincoln Riley's First Spring As Trojans Head Coach

Is USC Football Finally Back? Recapping Lincoln Riley's First Spring As Trojans Head Coach

We hear about 'culture changes' in college football all the time; one-season turnarounds ushered in...

ByBryan Armetta | Fri Jun 17 2022
Where to find the most Division III football championships

Where to find the most Division III football championships

At nearly 500 miles apart, two small Midwestern cities play host to a pair of college campuses. At...

ByBrice Odel | Thu Jun 16 2022